Games like Pony Island on Steam
For those who prefer not to search, lists of the most played, top deals and best free games like Pony Island are available at the bottom of the page.
Filters & Lists
Fragile
Get pulled into the nightmares of reality as you play as an abducted girl from the ger district of Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. Uncover a secret organization that deals in human trafficking and other horrendous activities. Try to escape from the scariest place on earth!
Rusty Lake Paradise
Rusty Lake Paradise is set on a small remote island which is cursed by the ten plagues of Egypt. Solve all the mysteries of this dark, macabre puzzle adventure. Paradise builds upon the distinctive atmosphere and excitement from the Rusty Lake series.
SORE
Mystical puzzle quest game in a gloomy minimalism style will tell you a story of a person who's got himself into a camera, and from which there is no way out it seems. Experimental gameplay diluted with a pinch of a philosophy, that's what SORE is.
Hello Charlotte EP2: Requiem Aeternam Deo
A eulogy for happiness, and a lament for connection that never was.
Rusty Lake: Roots
Experience the beginning and end of characters' lives and build your own family tree! Rusty Lake: Roots is the second premium point-and-click adventure by the creators of the Cube Escape series and Rusty Lake Hotel.
Plug & Play
Run, hit, switch, fall, love, plug, pull. And push.
Indigo Park: Chapter 1
Explore the abandoned childhood wonder of Indigo Park! Guided by Rambley the Raccoon, help restore power to the destroyed amusement park while you run from the reason it shut down.
Children of Silentown
Children of Silentown is a dark adventure game that tells the story of Lucy, a girl growing up in a village deep in a forest inhabited by monsters. People disappearing is nothing uncommon here, but this time, Lucy is old enough to investigate on her own. Or so she thinks.
My Beautiful Paper Smile
Welcome, child, to your new home. Here you shall learn the art of perfection. Here you shall learn to smile. Be sure that smile doesn’t fade into sadness, or you will need to run and hide…
Among the Sleep - Enhanced Edition
Among the Sleep: Enhanced Edition is a new and improved version of the award winning first person horror adventure. In the game you play as a small child trapped in a weird nightmare where you go looking for your mom.
The Mirror Lied
This isn't a horror game. Nothing will jump out at you.
The Executioner
The Executioner puts you in the shoes of a man who tortures people for a living while trying to retain his own sanity. In this game the monster isn’t lurking behind you. You are the monster, if you choose to become one.
Dropsy
Dropsy is a non-traditional take on the classic point and click adventure formula starring the game’s perpetually carefree namesake clown as he explores a richly detailed world full of colorful characters and sinister secrets, doling out hugs along the way.
Nightmare House: The Original Mod
Wake up, it’s time for the real nightmare to begin. Make your way through a terrorizing house, uncover the secrets of a haunted hospital, fight through hordes of the undead, and try to escape Nightmare House.
The Horror Of Salazar House
Will you solve the mystery of the Salazar manor or will you become another permanent inhabitant? An Italian horror inspired adventure game!
Burning Daylight
Waking up naked in a slaughterhouse, you must escape and travel through a dystopian world to uncover the truth of your origins. Burning Daylight is a sci-fi adventure game, set in a dystopian future with light puzzle elements and environmental storytelling.
The Crooked Man
There was a crooked man, and he walked a crooked mile... This is the first title in the series known as The Strange Man, developed by Uri Games. Experience the myriad horrors awaiting David as he moves into his new house.
My Big Sister
My name is Luzia...and this story isn't about me, it’s about my sister. Do you still wish to hear it?
FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY'S: HELP WANTED
Five Nights at Freddy’s: Help Wanted is a collection of classic and original mini-games set in the Five Nights universe. Experience the horror in flat (non-VR) mode or VR. Oculus Rift and HTC Vive are supported. A VR Headset is NOT required to play.
Jimmy and the Pulsating Mass
One day, Jimmy looked inside.Most played games like Pony Island on Steam
Take a look at the top games like Pony Island that are currently attracting the largest player bases on the Steam platform, as of April 19th 2025.
1. Undertale
Similarity 62% UNDERTALE! The RPG game where you don't have to destroy anyone. Undertale is a great soundtrack, story rich and choices matter game developed and published by tobyfox. Released on September 15th 2015 has received 264,189 reviews of which 255,536 were positive and 8,653 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. The game has hit the top spot as the #1 most played game like Pony Island, thanks to its 2,519 peak concurrent players over the last day.
9.6
255,536
8,653
2,519
players
2. Outer Wilds
Similarity 50% Named Game of the Year 2019 by Giant Bomb, Polygon, Eurogamer, and The Guardian, Outer Wilds is a critically-acclaimed and award-winning open world mystery about a solar system trapped in an endless time loop. Outer Wilds is a exploration, space and mystery game developed by Mobius Digital and published by Annapurna Interactive. Released on June 18th 2020 has received 81,971 reviews of which 78,436 were positive and 3,535 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. While seeing 1,234 players online at once in the last 24 hours, this game is currently ranked #2 among games like Pony Island based on player count.
9.4
78,436
3,535
1,234
players
3. Buckshot Roulette
Similarity 51% Play Russian roulette with a 12-gauge shotgun. Four enter. One leaves. Roll the dice with your life. Good luck! Buckshot Roulette is a multiplayer, dark and gambling game developed by Mike Klubnika and published by CRITICAL REFLEX. Released on April 04th 2024 has received 91,862 reviews of which 88,270 were positive and 3,592 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.5 out of 10. While seeing 1,174 players online at once in the last 24 hours, this game is currently ranked #3 among games like Pony Island based on player count.
9.5
88,270
3,592
1,174
players
4. A Little to the Left
Similarity 50% A Little to the Left is a cozy puzzle game that has you sort, stack, and organize household items into pleasing arrangements while you keep an eye out for a mischievous cat with an inclination for chaos. Check out this playful and intuitive puzzler with 100+ satisfying messes to tidy. A Little to the Left is a puzzle, relaxing and wholesome game developed by Max Inferno and published by Secret Mode. Released on November 08th 2022 has received 13,016 reviews of which 11,984 were positive and 1,032 were negative resulting in a rating of 9.0 out of 10. With 485 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #4 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.0
11,984
1,032
485
players
5. Little Nightmares
Similarity 59% Take on the role of Six, a lone child lost in a massive metal vessel known as the Maw, surrounded by dangerous, distorted versions of adults. You’ll need to do your best to escape in one piece or your fate will be worse than you ever dared dream. Little Nightmares is a horror, atmospheric and adventure game developed by Tarsier Studios and published by Bandai Namco Entertainment. Released on April 27th 2017 has received 109,132 reviews of which 103,460 were positive and 5,672 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.3 out of 10. With 325 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #5 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.3
103,460
5,672
325
players
6. Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair
Similarity 51% Jabberwock Island—You and your classmates were ready for fun in the sun until Monokuma returned to restart his murderous game! Trapped in a kill-or-be-killed situation, your only hope rests in solving the island’s mysteries. Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair is a anime, detective and visual novel game developed by Spike Chunsoft Co., Ltd. and Abstraction Games and published by Spike Chunsoft Co. and Ltd.. Released on April 18th 2016 has received 26,311 reviews of which 25,335 were positive and 976 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. With 249 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #6 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.4
25,335
976
249
players
7. Sally Face - Episode One
Similarity 62% Delve into a dark adventure following the boy with a prosthetic face and a tragic past. Unravel the sinister mysteries of Sally's world to find the truth that lies hidden beneath the shadows. Sally Face - Episode One is a story rich, psychological horror and indie game developed and published by Portable Moose. Released on December 14th 2016 has received 22,117 reviews of which 21,498 were positive and 619 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.5 out of 10. With 170 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #7 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.5
21,498
619
170
players
8. Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony
Similarity 51% A new cast of 16 characters find themselves kidnapped and imprisoned in a school. Inside, some will kill, some will die, and some will be punished. Reimagine what you thought high-stakes, fast-paced investigation was as you investigate twisted murder cases and condemn your new friends to death. Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony is a visual novel, detective and female protagonist game developed and published by Spike Chunsoft Co. and Ltd.. Released on September 25th 2017 has received 19,638 reviews of which 16,480 were positive and 3,158 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.2 out of 10. With 156 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #8 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
8.2
16,480
3,158
156
players
9. Little Nightmares II
Similarity 56% Little Nightmares II is the second game in a series that has thrilled and captivated millions of players worldwide since 2017. Now it’s your turn to try to survive this critically acclaimed entry in the most charming horror series ever made. Little Nightmares II is a horror, adventure and singleplayer game developed by Tarsier Studios and published by Bandai Namco Entertainment. Released on February 10th 2021 has received 42,152 reviews of which 39,665 were positive and 2,487 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.2 out of 10. With 151 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #9 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.2
39,665
2,487
151
players
10. Bendy and the Ink Machine
Similarity 60% Bendy and the Ink Machine® is the first person puzzle action horror game that will forever ruin your childhood love of cartoons. Bendy and the Ink Machine is a horror, first-person and singleplayer game developed and published by Joey Drew Studios. Released on April 27th 2017 has received 28,884 reviews of which 25,663 were positive and 3,221 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.7 out of 10. With 132 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #10 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
8.7
25,663
3,221
132
players
Best deals on games like Pony Island on Steam
Discover fantastic savings with the best discounts on a variety of games like Pony Island available on Steam right now, updated on April 19th 2025. Looking for even more deals? Use the search filters to explore a wider range of discounted games like Pony Island.
1. Ad Infinitum
Similarity 52% When reality is a nightmare, nightmares become real. In this psychological horror game, you fight the terrifying creatures invading your mind. Can you save your sanity? Ad Infinitum is a horror, action and psychological horror game developed by Hekate and published by Nacon. Released on September 14th 2023 has received 863 reviews of which 695 were positive and 168 were negative resulting in a rating of 7.7 out of 10. Featuring a massive 94% discount, this game currently holds the #1 spot in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
7.7
695
168
-94%
35.50€
2.13€
2. Children of Silentown
Similarity 55% Children of Silentown is a dark adventure game that tells the story of Lucy, a girl growing up in a village deep in a forest inhabited by monsters. People disappearing is nothing uncommon here, but this time, Lucy is old enough to investigate on her own. Or so she thinks. Children of Silentown is a atmospheric, point & click and adventure game developed by Elf Games and Luna2 Studio and published by Daedalic Entertainment. Released on January 11th 2023 has received 1,267 reviews of which 1,103 were positive and 164 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.3 out of 10. Thanks to its incredible 93% discount, this game is now the #2 best deal in games like Pony Island.
8.3
1,103
164
-93%
19.71€
1.38€
3. The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
Similarity 51% The Excavation of Hob's Barrow is a folk horror narrative-driven adventure. Explore the isolated moors of rural Victorian England as you uncover the mysteries of Hob's Barrow. The answers lie in the soil... The Excavation of Hob's Barrow is a point & click, adventure and horror game developed by Cloak and Dagger Games and published by Wadjet Eye Games. Released on September 28th 2022 has received 2,377 reviews of which 2,204 were positive and 173 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.9 out of 10. Thanks to its incredible 92% discount, this game is now the #3 best deal in games like Pony Island.
8.9
2,204
173
-92%
12.50€
1.00€
4. TSIOQUE
Similarity 52% TSIOQUE (pronounced: "chiock") is a dark but playful Point & Click adventure, hand-animated in meticulous, frame-by-frame 2D. Escape the clutches of an Evil Wizard and discover the secrets hidden within the spellbound castle of your ancestors. TSIOQUE is a adventure, point & click and indie game developed by OhNoo Studio and Smile and published by OhNoo Studio. Released on November 07th 2018 has received 1,792 reviews of which 1,702 were positive and 90 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.0 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 91% discount, this title has earned the #4 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
9.0
1,702
90
-91%
11.11€
1.00€
5. Don't Escape: 4 Days to Survive
Similarity 54% Survive through four days at the end of the world in this post-apocalyptic point-and-click thriller where your choices could keep you alive... or not. Don't Escape: 4 Days to Survive is a adventure, pixel graphics and point & click game developed by scriptwelder and published by Armor Games Studios. Released on March 11th 2019 has received 2,219 reviews of which 2,176 were positive and 43 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.3 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 90% discount, this title has earned the #5 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
9.3
2,176
43
-90%
14.70€
1.47€
6. Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition
Similarity 57% Surrounded by enemies and assaulted by terror from all sides, Philip must collect clues and solve vexing puzzles while combating the gnawing psychological terrors that assail his mind and threaten to strip him of his sanity. Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition is a horror, adventure and first-person game developed and published by Frictional Games. Released on January 23rd 2009 has received 2,725 reviews of which 2,564 were positive and 161 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 90% discount, this title has earned the #6 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
9
2,564
161
-90%
9.75€
0.97€
7. Penumbra Overture
Similarity 51% Penumbra: Overture is a first person survival horror game, emphasizing on survival and problem solving instead of mindless violence and gore. Penumbra Overture is a horror, adventure and first-person game developed and published by Frictional Games. Released on March 06th 2009 has received 3,733 reviews of which 3,374 were positive and 359 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.7 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 90% discount, this title has earned the #7 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
8.7
3,374
359
-90%
9.75€
0.97€
8. Pinstripe
Similarity 56% An ex-minister ventures through the frozen depths of Hell in search of his kidnapped daughter. Pinstripe is a indie, adventure and casual game developed by Atmos Games and LLC and published by Armor Games Studios. Released on April 24th 2017 has received 2,514 reviews of which 2,243 were positive and 271 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.6 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 90% discount, this title has earned the #8 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
8.6
2,243
271
-90%
14.79€
1.47€
9. Anna's Quest
Similarity 60% With her telekinesis, unorthodox use of torture instruments, a knack for improvisation and the help of a shady fox she makes her way from the peaks of Glass Mountain to the deepest dungeon. Anna's Quest is a adventure, point & click and indie game developed and published by Daedalic Entertainment. Released on July 02nd 2015 has received 2,310 reviews of which 2,034 were positive and 276 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.4 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 90% discount, this title has earned the #9 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
8.4
2,034
276
-90%
19.99€
1.99€
10. Dead Synchronicity: Tomorrow Comes Today
Similarity 60% A dying reality, a universe that’s fading away. A merciless world thatgets sick and vanishes. No past, no present, no future; only the impending moment of “dead synchronicity” ahead. Will you be able to stop it?Because, otherwise... what will you do when Time dissolves itself? Dead Synchronicity: Tomorrow Comes Today is a adventure, point & click and indie game developed by Fictiorama Studios and published by Daedalic Entertainment. Released on April 10th 2015 has received 1,461 reviews of which 1,222 were positive and 239 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.0 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 90% discount, this title has earned the #10 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
8.0
1,222
239
-90%
9.99€
0.99€
Free games like Pony Island on Steam
Check out this fantastic list of free-to-play games like Pony Island you can enjoy on Steam right now, updated on April 19th 2025. Looking for even more free titles? Use the search filters to explore a wider range of free to play games like Pony Island.
1. Cube Escape: Paradox
Similarity 60% The tenth Cube Escape follows the story of detective Dale Vandermeer who finds himself trapped in two different universes and needs to escape. Cube Escape: Paradox will be released together with the accompanying Paradox: A Rusty Lake Film. Cube Escape: Paradox is a puzzle, free to play and psychological horror game developed and published by Rusty Lake. Released on September 20th 2018 has received 10,295 reviews of which 10,013 were positive and 282 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #1 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
10,013
282
82
players
2. Yume Nikki
Similarity 57% This is a game in which you traverse the extremely dark world inside a dream. Yume Nikki is a indie, free to play and psychological horror game developed by kikiyama and published by PLAYISM. Released on January 09th 2018 has received 8,442 reviews of which 7,937 were positive and 505 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.1 out of 10. The game currently holds the #2 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.1
7,937
505
55
players
3. Indigo Park: Chapter 1
Similarity 55% Explore the abandoned childhood wonder of Indigo Park! Guided by Rambley the Raccoon, help restore power to the destroyed amusement park while you run from the reason it shut down. Indigo Park: Chapter 1 is a horror, free to play and first-person game developed and published by UniqueGeese. Released on May 18th 2024 has received 20,601 reviews of which 19,682 were positive and 919 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.3 out of 10. The game currently holds the #3 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.3
19,682
919
42
players
4. Paper Lily - Chapter 1
Similarity 51% Paper Lily is an RPG horror game in which you can solve puzzles in different ways. Explore a hidden world, meet strange characters, and guide Lacie as she attempts to find answers about her unusual condition. Paper Lily - Chapter 1 is a pixel graphics, psychological horror and anime game developed and published by Leef 6010. Released on January 26th 2024 has received 6,184 reviews of which 6,128 were positive and 56 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. The game currently holds the #4 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.6
6,128
56
40
players
5. Outcore: Desktop Adventure
Similarity 54% All you wanted was a nice game. But now you find yourself opening Windows apps like Paint & Notepad to solve puzzles, and searching for files on your computers that you didn't put there... Who is she? Why did she appear on your desktop? Let's dive into her memories and find out. Outcore: Desktop Adventure is a adventure, free to play and psychological horror game developed and published by Doctor Shinobi. Released on September 26th 2022 has received 14,818 reviews of which 14,422 were positive and 396 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.5 out of 10. The game currently holds the #5 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.5
14,422
396
30
players
6. Samsara Room
Similarity 52% You woke up in a mysterious room you have never seen before. Can you find another way out? Samsara Room is a remake of the praised predecessor of the Rusty Lake & Cube Escape series. Samsara Room is a indie, adventure and puzzle game developed and published by Rusty Lake. Released on April 29th 2020 has received 9,022 reviews of which 8,781 were positive and 241 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #6 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
8,781
241
20
players
7. Nightmare House: The Original Mod
Similarity 54% Wake up, it’s time for the real nightmare to begin. Make your way through a terrorizing house, uncover the secrets of a haunted hospital, fight through hordes of the undead, and try to escape Nightmare House. Nightmare House: The Original Mod is a free to play, horror and action-adventure game developed and published by We Create Stuff. Released on November 14th 2024 has received 1,258 reviews of which 1,223 were positive and 35 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.2 out of 10. The game currently holds the #7 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.2
1,223
35
17
players
8. Dr. Langeskov, The Tiger, and The Terribly Cursed Emerald: A Whirlwind Heist
Similarity 50% A 15 minute heist game by Crows Crows Crows & Directed by William Pugh (The Stanley Parable). Slip into the soft-soled shoes of the mastermind responsible for the greatest heist- oh god I can’t do this any more, i’m joining the strike. good luck writing the steam description. -tina Dr. Langeskov, The Tiger, and The Terribly Cursed Emerald: A Whirlwind Heist is a free to play, comedy and first-person game developed and published by Crows Crows Crows. Released on December 04th 2015 has received 9,717 reviews of which 9,059 were positive and 658 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.1 out of 10. The game currently holds the #8 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.1
9,059
658
5
players
9. There Is No Game: Jam Edition 2015
Similarity 51% A little game that’s not a game, winner of an old game jam that nobody’s ever heard of. So DON'T INSTALL IT! There Is No Game: Jam Edition 2015 is a indie, free to play and casual game developed and published by Draw Me A Pixel. Released on March 18th 2020 has received 6,961 reviews of which 6,745 were positive and 216 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #9 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
6,745
216
3
players
10. Hello Charlotte EP2: Requiem Aeternam Deo
Similarity 56% A eulogy for happiness, and a lament for connection that never was. Hello Charlotte EP2: Requiem Aeternam Deo is a psychological horror, 2d and rpg game developed and published by etherane. Released on November 21st 2016 has received 1,880 reviews of which 1,828 were positive and 52 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.2 out of 10. The game currently holds the #10 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.2
1,828
52
3
players